To many television viewers, HBO’s March 14 decision to cancel Luck
after three horses died during production seemed to come from out of
the blue. But for weeks, HBO had been under pressure from People for the
Ethical Treatment of Animals, which had written to the premium cable
channel raising questions about the treatment of horses on the series
from executive producers Michael Mann and David Milch.
The animal-rights organization first inquired about Luck in
January, prompting HBO to respond that it was following strict safety
protocols. PETA responded with detailed questions Jan. 25, Feb. 1 and
Feb. 3. On Feb. 7, HBO responded briefly, reiterating its commitment to
safety. In March, PETA wrote again to express alarm — days before the
third horse’s death. Below are excerpts from the correspondence.
